Summary: The implementation of the labour codes necessitates a comprehensive review of compensation paid to employees. The compensation structure of employees will also see an impact from an income tax perspective, which cannot be ignored easily. Through this blog, we have analysed some of the positive as well as negative consequences that would need to be understood and analysed by employers as well as employees at the earliest.Continue Reading Tax implications of the new labour codes
Summary: The Multilateral Instrument (MLI), which had originated from the OECD’s BEPS project, was meant to fast-track adoption of anti-avoidance measures without lengthy bilateral negotiations between multiple countries. India ratified the MLI in 2019 and the Revenue argued vociferously before the Supreme Court in the case of Nestle that every change to the DTAA shall have to be notified separately to give effect to such change and succeeded. Following the aforesaid SC decision, a few recent ITAT judgments have thrown a curveball by holding that MLI provisions cannot apply automatically to the DTAAs unless a specific notification is issued. Through this blog, we analyse the impact of these ITAT decisions, which may reshape ongoing tax litigation strategies.Continue Reading As you sow, so you reap: ITAT holds MLI provisions adopted in DTAAs inapplicable without specific notification
The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal’s (“ITAT”) Chennai bench in Zoho Corporation Pvt. Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax,[1] determined that foreign taxes paid by an assessee, which do not qualify for relief under Sections 90 or 91 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (“IT Act”), cannot be claimed as business expense deduction under Section 37(1).Continue Reading Foreign taxes cannot be allowed as tax deductible expenditure: Chennai ITAT
The question of whether cross-border services rendered by foreign entities would establish a taxable presence in India has been subject to nuanced scrutiny. In a recent ruling,[1] the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India (“SC”) has reaffirmed that economic substance (not legal form) is the crucial factor for determining whether a foreign entity exercises substantive control over Indian operations to constitute a permanent establishment (“PE”) in India.Continue Reading Substance over Form: Supreme Court Clarification on Creation of Permanent Establishment in Cross-Border Services
Businesses are increasingly integrating cloud computing models into their operations, necessitating unambiguity regarding the position of tax leviable on such transactions under the Income-Tax Act, 1961 (“IT Act”), and tax treaties. Uniformity in the tax treatment of cross-border cloud computing models has become crucial for these businesses to plan their operations and tax costs effectively. A long-standing subject of scrutiny has been whether to consider the taxation of payment for cross-border cloud services as “royalties” or “fee for technical services” (“FTS”)/ “fee for included services” (“FIS”). However, in recent rulings, Indian courts have affirmed that such standardised services would not be liable to income tax in India.Continue Reading Debunking taxation of cloud services as royalty
In a tax system as vast and complex as India’s, time-bound adjudication is not merely a procedural ideal, it is also an essential pillar that promotes ease of doing business, upholds taxpayer trust, promotes administrative efficiency, and sustains the integrity of revenue collection. On the other hand, persistence of cases where adjudication lingers for a decade or more raises troubling questions.Continue Reading Time bound adjudication by revenue authorities: A distant dream or plausible reality?
The India–Mauritius Double Tax Avoidance Agreement (“DTAA”), entered into in 1983, has since been the subject matter of contentious litigations. The well-drafted and reasoned ruling of the Delhi High Court (“Delhi HC”), which explains the availability of benefits to a Mauritius-based investor, the significance of the tax residency certificate (“TRC”), the limitation of benefits (“LoB”) clause, and the grandfathering provision in the treaty, has provided much-anticipated relief and certainty to the taxpayers.Continue Reading Delhi High Court grants tax-treaty benefits to Tiger Global’s Flipkart exit
The provisions of General Anti-Avoidance Rules (“GAAR”) were implemented into Income Tax Act, 1961 (“IT Act”), for the first time with effect from the financial year 2017–18. The GAAR provisions provide the Indian Revenue Authorities (“IRA”) with wide powers, including even recharacterising a transaction, ignoring a part or the whole of a series of transactions, disallowing expenses incurred, etc., if the main purpose of the transaction was to obtain tax benefits. Considering the aggressive nature in which the IRA generally scrutinises the GAAR cases, the industry is always apprehensive that these GAAR provisions could be invoked in a wide-spread manner. However, much to the relief of the taxpayers, the IRA have rarely invoked these provisions.Continue Reading First judgment on GAAR holds bonus-stripping to be an impermissible tax-avoidance arrangement
In a significant decision delivered recently, the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi (“Hon’ble HC”) has shot down the case of the Income Tax Department (“ITD”) wherein the ITD had alleged three kinds of permanent establishments (“PE”). In Progress Rail Locomotive Inc.[1] (“Assessee”), the ITD intended to target the Assessee by putting it in all three conceivable PE silos i.e., Fixed Place PE, Service PE and dependent agent PE (“DAPE”) and used it as reasons to reopen the case. The Hon’ble HC rejected the contentions of the ITD by holding them to be prima facie unsustainable.Continue Reading Delhi HC delivers an important pronouncement on permanent establishment
The Tax Deducted at Source (“TDS”) provisions under the Indian Income Tax Act of 1961 (“IT Act”) have been the cornerstone of the country’s tax architecture. A payer (or a deductor) is expected to be vigilant at the time of entering into any transaction, so that the required taxes are duly deducted and deposited with the Government where required, to avoid any adverse implications including penal consequences later. TDS mechanism, under Indian tax laws, has been a useful tool to collect taxes, targeting income at source itself. Continue Reading Are TDS provisions tedious? Opportune time for simplification